lenny

Worlds Collide: Fiction & Fact

user image

Lesson Plan

Worlds Collide: Fiction & Fact

Students will be able to analyze and compare how a shared theme is developed in both a fiction and a non-fiction text, identifying similarities and differences in perspective, purpose, and literary/rhetorical devices.

Understanding how different types of texts explore the same ideas helps students develop stronger critical thinking skills, preparing them for complex academic and real-world texts. This lesson enhances their ability to analyze information from multiple angles.

Audience

9th Grade Students

Time

30 minutes

Approach

Students will read two paired passages, answer multiple-choice questions, and write a comparative essay.

Materials

Worlds Collide: Fiction & Fact Slide Deck, Journey to the Stars: Fiction Passage, The Science of Starlight: Non-Fiction Reading, Worlds Collide: Comprehension Quiz, and Worlds Collide: Essay Prompt Journal

Prep

Review Materials and Prepare Copies

15 minutes

Step 1

Introduction & Hook

5 minutes

  • Begin by presenting the Worlds Collide: Fiction & Fact Slide Deck (Slide 1-2).
    - Engage students with a brief discussion: "Have you ever noticed how different stories or articles can talk about the same big ideas, but in totally different ways? Today, we're going to explore that!"

Step 2

Paired Passage Reading

10 minutes

Step 3

Comprehension & Comparison

5 minutes

Step 4

Essay Prompt & Independent Writing

10 minutes

  • Introduce the essay prompt using the Worlds Collide: Essay Prompt Journal.
    - Explain the expectations for comparing and contrasting the two texts based on the common theme.
    - Students begin writing independently. Collect at the end of class or assign as homework.
lenny
0 educators
use Lenny to create lessons.

No credit card needed

Slide Deck

Worlds Collide: Fiction & Fact

Exploring a Shared Theme Across Different Worlds

Ever wondered how different types of stories can still talk about the same big ideas? Today, we're going to find out!

Welcome students and introduce the captivating title: 'Worlds Collide: Fiction & Fact'. Ask them to ponder what this title might suggest about today's lesson. Encourage initial thoughts on how different stories or articles might share similar big ideas.

Our Mission Today

We will:

  • Read two passages: one fiction, one non-fiction.
  • Identify a common theme between them.
  • Compare and contrast how that theme is presented.
  • Answer questions and write an essay comparing the texts.

Explain the concept of paired passages and what students will be doing today. Emphasize the objective: understanding how a theme is developed in both fiction and non-fiction.

Ready, Set, Read!

Let's dive into our passages. As you read, think about:

  • What is each text about?
  • What big idea or message is each text trying to convey?
  • How do the authors make you feel or think?

Transition to the reading activity. Remind students to actively read and look for connections and thematic elements.

Time to Connect!

Now that you've read both passages, it's time to test your understanding and make those connections.

Complete the comprehension quiz individually. Afterwards, we'll discuss as a class!

Explain the task for the quiz. Mention that the quiz assesses comprehension and initial comparisons.

Your Turn to Write!

For our final task, you'll put your analytical skills to the test.

  • Compare and contrast how the common theme is explored in both the fiction and non-fiction passages.
  • Use specific examples and evidence from both texts to support your points.

Introduce the essay prompt. Clearly state the expectations for comparing and contrasting. Encourage students to use evidence from both texts.

Great Work, Analysts!

Today, you've learned to see how different stories and facts can speak to the same universal truths. This skill helps you understand the world in a richer, more connected way.

Conclude the lesson by reinforcing the value of analyzing different text types.

lenny

Reading

Journey to the Stars

The year was 2342, and Captain Eva Rostova stood on the gleaming bridge of the Stardust Voyager, her eyes fixed on the shimmering expanse of the Horsehead Nebula. For twenty years, she had dreamed of this moment, of leading humanity's first interstellar mission to a truly alien star system. The journey had been long, the sacrifices many, but the promise of discovery, of something utterly new, fueled every beat of her heart.

Her first officer, Jax, a stoic but brilliant xenolinguist, approached quietly. "Sensors are picking up anomalous energy readings from Kepler-186f, Captain. It's consistent with complex organic structures, far beyond anything we've ever encountered."

Eva felt a thrill, a familiar mixture of trepidation and exhilarating hope. Kepler-186f, a planet once thought to be merely a distant, rocky sphere, now beckoned with the whisper of life. They had traveled light-years, crossing the vast, silent ocean between suns, driven by an insatiable human urge to know what lay beyond.

As they descended through the planet's azure atmosphere, a landscape of towering, bioluminescent fungi and rivers of liquid methane unfolded beneath them. The air, though thin, carried the scent of alien flora, a perfume unlike anything on Earth. Eva knew then, with a certainty that resonated deep within her bones, that this wasn't just a mission; it was a revelation. Humanity was not alone, and the universe was infinitely more wondrous than they had ever dared to imagine. This journey wasn't just about finding new worlds, but about understanding their own place in a cosmic tapestry woven with endless possibilities.

lenny
lenny

Reading

The Science of Starlight

For millennia, humanity has gazed at the stars, driven by an innate curiosity about what lies beyond our earthly confines. This ancient fascination has evolved into the sophisticated field of astrophysics and exoplanetary science, pushing the boundaries of human knowledge and technological innovation.

The discovery of exoplanets—planets orbiting stars other than our Sun—has revolutionized our understanding of the universe. The Kepler Space Telescope, launched in 2009, was instrumental in identifying thousands of these distant worlds. Its primary method involved observing slight dips in a star's brightness, indicative of a planet passing in front of it, a phenomenon known as a transit.

One particularly intriguing discovery was Kepler-186f, the first Earth-size planet found in the habitable zone of another star. While we cannot directly observe life on such a distant world, its position within the 'Goldilocks zone'—where temperatures are just right for liquid water to exist on the surface—makes it a prime candidate for further study. Scientists use sophisticated instruments, like the James Webb Space Telescope, to analyze the atmospheres of exoplanets for biosignatures, chemical indicators of life.

These scientific endeavors are not just about finding new planets; they are about understanding the origins of life, the conditions necessary for its existence, and ultimately, our place in the vast cosmos. The relentless pursuit of knowledge, driven by advanced technology and human ingenuity, continues to unveil the universe's most profound secrets, transforming speculative fiction into scientific possibility.

lenny
lenny

Quiz

Worlds Collide: Comprehension Quiz

lenny

Journal

Worlds Collide: Essay Prompt

Prompt: Both "Journey to the Stars" (fiction) and "The Science of Starlight" (non-fiction) explore the theme of humanity's engagement with space. Write an essay that compares and contrasts how this common theme is developed in each text.

Consider the following in your response:

  • How do the authors use different literary or rhetorical devices to convey their message?
  • What is the primary purpose of each text (e.g., to entertain, inform, inspire, warn)?
  • How do the different genres (fiction vs. non-fiction) influence the reader's understanding and emotional response to the theme?
  • Support your points with specific examples and evidence from both passages.































lenny
lenny

Answer Key

Worlds Collide: Comprehension Quiz Answer Key

Question 1: In "Journey to the Stars," what is Captain Rostova's primary motivation for the interstellar mission?

  • Correct Answer: To discover something utterly new and alien
  • Thought Process: The text states, "the promise of discovery, of something utterly new, fueled every beat of her heart." This highlights her intrinsic drive for novel exploration.

Question 2: According to "The Science of Starlight," what method did the Kepler Space Telescope primarily use to detect exoplanets?

  • Correct Answer: Detecting dips in star brightness during transits
  • Thought Process: The passage explicitly states, "Its primary method involved observing slight dips in a star's brightness, indicative of a planet passing in front of it, a phenomenon known as a transit."

Question 3: Which planet is mentioned in both the fiction and non-fiction passages?

  • Correct Answer: Kepler-186f
  • Thought Process: Both passages refer to Kepler-186f as a distant planet of interest—the destination in the fiction and a key scientific discovery in the non-fiction.

Question 4: What is a common theme explored in both "Journey to the Stars" and "The Science of Starlight"? Provide a brief explanation.

  • Sample Answer: A common theme is humanity's innate drive for exploration and discovery in space. In "Journey to the Stars," this is shown through Captain Rostova's personal ambition to explore new alien worlds and the wonders encountered. In "The Science of Starlight," it's evident in the historical human fascination with stars and the scientific pursuit of knowledge about exoplanets and the origins of life.

Question 5: How does the tone of "Journey to the Stars" differ from "The Science of Starlight"?

  • Correct Answer: "Journey to the Stars" is adventurous and imaginative, while "The Science of Starlight" is informative and factual.
  • Thought Process: "Journey to the Stars" uses evocative language and describes personal feelings (thrill, hope) and alien landscapes, characteristic of an imaginative narrative. "The Science of Starlight" uses precise terminology (astrophysics, exoplanetary science, biosignatures) and focuses on methods and discoveries, indicative of an informative, factual tone.
lenny
lenny