lenny

Beyond Black & White

Lesson Plan

Beyond Black & White Lesson Plan

Students will be able to identify and define 'black and white thinking' and analyze its impact on understanding complex issues and relationships.

Understanding black and white thinking helps students develop critical thinking skills, improve communication, and approach challenges with greater flexibility and empathy.

Audience

10th Grade

Time

30 minutes

Approach

Interactive discussion, real-world examples, and a reflection activity.

Materials

Beyond Black & White Slide Deck, Black & White Thinking Scenario Cards, and Thinking in Shades Journal

Prep

Prepare Materials & Review

15 minutes

Step 1

Warm-Up: Agree or Disagree

5 minutes

  • Display a statement on the board or projector, such as: 'There is always a right and wrong answer.'
    - Ask students to physically move to one side of the room if they 'Agree' and the other side if they 'Disagree'.
    - Briefly facilitate a quick-fire discussion, asking a few students from each side to explain their stance without going into too much detail. Introduce the idea that sometimes things aren't so clear-cut.

Step 2

Introduction to Black and White Thinking

10 minutes

  • Use the Beyond Black & White Slide Deck to define 'black and white thinking' (also known as dichotomous thinking or all-or-nothing thinking).
    - Provide clear examples (e.g., 'If I'm not perfect, I'm a complete failure,' 'You're either with us or against us').
    - Discuss the potential impact of this thinking style on relationships, problem-solving, and personal well-being.

Step 3

Activity: Scenario Exploration

10 minutes

  • Divide students into small groups (3-4 students).
    - Distribute the Black & White Thinking Scenario Cards to each group.
    - Instruct groups to read each scenario and discuss how black and white thinking is present. Then, challenge them to brainstorm more nuanced, 'shades of gray' perspectives or solutions.
    - Circulate among groups to facilitate discussion and offer guidance.

Step 4

Cool-Down: Thinking in Shades Reflection

5 minutes

  • Bring the class back together.
    - Ask each group to share one scenario and their 'shades of gray' perspective.
    - Distribute the Thinking in Shades Journal for students to complete individually as an exit ticket or homework, reflecting on how they can apply more nuanced thinking in their own lives.
lenny
0 educators
use Lenny to create lessons.

No credit card needed

Slide Deck

Beyond Black & White

How often do things seem truly 'either/or'?

Welcome students and introduce the day's topic. Start with an engaging question to activate prior knowledge or provoke thought related to clear-cut answers versus complexities.

Warm-Up: Agree or Disagree?

Statement: 'There is always a right and wrong answer for every problem.'

  • Move to one side of the room if you Agree.
  • Move to the other side if you Disagree.

Explain the Warm-Up activity: 'Agree or Disagree'. Present a statement and have students physically move to show their stance. Emphasize that there's no right or wrong answer for the warm-up, just an exploration of initial thoughts.

What is Black & White Thinking?

It's seeing the world in extremes:

  • All or Nothing: 'If I'm not perfect, I'm a complete failure.'
  • Either/Or: 'You're either with me or against me.'
  • Good vs. Bad: People/situations are entirely one or the other.

Also known as: Dichotomous Thinking or All-or-Nothing Thinking.

Introduce the concept of 'black and white thinking' clearly. Use simple language and relatable metaphors. Provide alternative terms like 'all-or-nothing thinking' or 'dichotomous thinking.'

The Impact of Black & White Thinking

How can this way of thinking affect us?

  • Relationships: Difficulty with compromise, quick judgments.
  • Problem-Solving: Limits creative solutions, creates rigid thinking.
  • Self-Perception: Harsh self-criticism, fear of mistakes.
  • Understanding Complex Issues: Oversimplification, lack of empathy.

Discuss the potential negative consequences of this thinking style. Prompt students to think about how it might affect their own lives or interactions with others.

Activity: Scenario Exploration

In your small groups:

  1. Read each Black & White Thinking Scenario Card.
  2. Discuss how black and white thinking is present in the scenario.
  3. Brainstorm and write down more nuanced, 'shades of gray' perspectives or solutions for each.

Transition to the group activity. Explain the instructions for the 'Scenario Exploration' clearly. Emphasize moving beyond the initial 'black and white' interpretation to find 'shades of gray.'

Cool-Down: Thinking in Shades

Let's share our 'shades of gray' perspectives!

Take a few minutes to complete your Thinking in Shades Journal to reflect on today's lesson.

Conclude the lesson by bringing the class back together for a brief share-out and introducing the reflection journal. Explain that the journal is a way to solidify their understanding individually.

lenny